rel=nofollowattribute which tells Google not to raise the PageRank of the link target when my blog's PageRank otherwise would have. A full stop to link love.
I'm not going to say that rel=nofollow is a bad solution, period, though I agree to a large extent. Not having this damage control, when CAPTCHA fails, would add further to the sploggers' incentive of posting their junk wherever they can, which is of course a bad thing (see, I already firmly decided that we agreed on that, you might recall). I think
rel=nofollowhas its purpose, but I would also like to share link love where link love is due, and I would like it to be a very easy thing to do -- just a click away in some comment moderation view. Today, Blogger unconditionally adds the
rel=nofollowattribute to all links in your comments, providing neither the option not to, nor the tools to manage this on a post by post basis.
It shouldn't be wasted effort writing good comments, tying together relevant links across the web, even though the few humans directly addressed by a comment might follow the links, unaware of the invisible search engine deterrents sprayed across those links.
I'll settle for something which solves this problem for me and other Blogger users who feel the same way I do, and I think I have an embryo of an idea growing, already. In researching unrelated topics (how to inline the post a comment form in your own Blogger page layout at Jasper de Vries' Browservulsel, and also at the Singpolyma technical blog) I happened upon an article about how to edit Blogger comments posted to your blog, post factum -- and not only yours, but all others, too. Interesting. Each comment on your Blogger blog is technically a blog post, just like your own, and can thus be edited in the Blogger post editor, if you have the rights to. Which you do, when the comment is put in your blog.
History falsification issues aside, this is a really good thing. It means not only that you can go back, correct spelling mistakes you did without posting a new comment and removing the old one, or that you can tidy up posts by others, but it also means that we can fix the
rel=nofollowissue when we get somre really good links. Because the HTML we get to edit is not the same HTML the commenter wrote when submitting, it is the post-processed HTML that eventually ends up on your blog. I tried, and yes, editing out the
rel=nofollowattribute is done in a snap. Works like a charm.
It's not the one click away story in a comments overview I'd like it to be, though. Jasper has made a handy Greasemonkey script to add comment edit links (and if you read the article on how to edit comments, you also know that you could edit your Blogger template to provide these links yourself), which of course helps, but I'm pondering the next generation of precision automation, doing away just with the
rel=nofollowattribute at the click of a button, and without loading any other page in doing so (because then it would not just be clickety-clickety-click when you have three good comments on a post, but also lots of waiting and clicking back, rinse, repeat).
I envision a nifty little Greasemonkey hack which tracks down the comments that have links still marked Google hates your guts, and adds a little heart icon () to it, which, when clicked, fires away an XMLHttpRequest behind the scenes that edits this comment, and when it has succeeded, removes the heart from the comment (since there is no more any need to add any link love there). Points for style awarded for pulsating the heart while this is happening behind the scenes.
And, as it happens, I already tried out how that can be done in a previous, less useful hack of mine where I submit images to ImageShack, which is probably done a lot better with their own Firefox context-menu extension. But it was a useful learning experience, nevertheless, and I did write that image pulsation code. :-)
There, I think that pretty much sums it up. And while this would technically qualify for my Some assembly required blog, I wanted to focus a bit more on the discussion side to it, so I'll just post a back referral and a summary there. Feel free to join in; this will be a fun and worthy hack.